fairyd123

First part of my season 1 recs master list.

Horror is a bit of a vague category so the list encompasses darker stories which leave you with a feeling of unease.

Decomposure by Paperbkywriter

Gen

After Sam is killed on a hunt Dean turns to an old adversary to bring him back. But reanimating a psychic has unexpected side effects with Sam re-born as a psi-vampire. Disturbing, compelling and very sad with a pitch perfect Dean voice.

More Glory to Their Eyes Than Blood by

fryadvocate

Sam/Dean

Extraordinary post apocalyptic story which has Sam and Dean menaced by an unseen threat - "the jungle". Economical in its set up, highly atmospheric and dripping with a sense of despair the story effortlessly creates an atmosphere of real unease which lingers long after you've finished reading.

The Thousand Ways To Bleed by

lithiumdoll

Slight Sam/Dean

Shades of Groundhog Day in a brilliantly eerie story featuring a disturbingly insane Dean.

The Fall From Grace in Ten Easy Steps by

maygra

Sam/Dean

Ten beautifully crafted drabbles which gave me the shivers. Nine and Ten are just plain haunting.

The Sound and the Fury by

follow_midnight

Gen

Dean is possessed and violently attacks his family. Dark as hell and almost unbearable to read as a catalogue of absolute horrors is unleashed on the Winchester boys.

The Good Son by

witchofthedogs

Gen with references to Wincest

Dean makes a deal with the devil. Brilliant Dean characterisation and extremely bleak.

Wound So Tight by

trollprincess

Gen Dean/OFC

Post Devil's Trap the demon possesses Sam. This story is essentially Dean's worst nightmare bought to life. Affecting.

Pack up the Moon by

trollprincess

Sam/Dean

Future fic in which Sam's powers have become deadly and completely out of his control.